[yutgjctguc]

Hello,

This is related to other threads about changing to v5p. Should we do a vote with the Community Input Panel? Then everyone could vote in there. Especially players who has no forum account

[Quest]

Hello,

This is related to other threads about changing to v5p. Should we do a vote with the Community Input Panel? Then everyone could vote in there. Especially players who has no forum account

The only issue with this is that new players/minges will just click any button and it wouldn't be a true vote

[Bambo]

Everything considered, there was already a vote about the v5p. Everyone voted for Rockford. If we constantly change maps instead of grow in one, that is going to make people's dupes worthless. There was a vote for v5p, community voted for Rockford.

[Nev]

Constantly change maps?
It's been months.

Map-vote currently in progress shows a large favor for V5P.

[Soviethooves]

Everything considered, there was already a vote about the v5p. Everyone voted for Rockford. If we constantly change maps instead of grow in one, that is going to make people's dupes worthless. There was a vote for v5p, community voted for Rockford.

I tried to tell them.

[Soviethooves]

Hello,

This is related to other threads about changing to v5p. Should we do a vote with the Community Input Panel? Then everyone could vote in there. Especially players who has no forum account

The only issue with this is that new players/minges will just click any button and it wouldn't be a true vote

It was made for the specific reason to let anyone that plays on our server vote. Knowledge or none, they still have that right if they use ll’s services.

[Nev]

It's a little pathetic how hard you're trying to push your favor of Rockford tbh, community poll currently stands that more people want V5P.

Even the previous map vote showed a favor of V5P over Rockford on the forums, but I bet you pushed really hard to get it into the F1 menu so randoms can vote on it and you could really push for it on players in-game. Bet if I was active at that time, it'd have a different outcome because I'm sure after explaining all the cons to Rockford and the pros to V5P the vote would've had a different outcome

Rockford zero RP value, crap buildings, crap roads, crap police station, no offices, no room for clan builds (reason why every admin clan builds custom areas), no city feeling, crap optimization (literally giant buildings and blocks textured as trees), fire station that is bigger than all passive rp stores combined, empty spaces everywhere that don't look good, invisible walls, fake buildings everywhere that you can't access, town hall sucks with a basic courtroom on the floor level that nobody is going to use because it doesn't look like a court room, bank that has a broken vault that glitches through the map, slums across from town hall?, gas station stores that are filled and cannot be used for any RP, mesa apartments that are crap and don't actually offer room for additional RP ideas such as running an apartment building or hotel and having a reception area to check people in, cinema that takes up a good chunk of the upper city and isn't used/needed, shops facing a cliff near inner shell that have low visibility and foot traffic and nobody uses, RTA/Realtor buildings are ugly asf and can't be used for RP, industrial area that doesn't even look good and is placed next to downtown and makes it a 10 second drive from PD and has high foot traffic so this makes these areas useless for actual criminal builds not to mention the industrial spaces are huge boxes with poor lighting making them impossible to properly decorate or use for RP (exception being when you're an admin with unlimited props), industrial area middle building isn't used because it's crap and uses flat PHX materials for the exterior and interior and has no room for any meaningful RP usage, three copy and pasted warehouses outside of town lack any good qualities for RP builds, just randomly placed at the end of a road, pier is sad waterfront builds are hideous, lake homes are probably the only semi-decent buildings on the map along with the tavern and some suburban homes, and they are only used for contraband for that reason. GM is a waste of space, filled with crap and look terrible.

Your argument against evocity was that you liked it but that it's sticking in the past and that it's a lagfest and that it's too spaced out, however as stated in the thread those things aren't true. We've never run V5P, it's the same if not better in optimization as Rockford and it functions just as well with 50 players on. There's nobody being spread out hiding, people would actually use the downtown to RP and not be cramped at 190 Main St which is the standalone box shop on Rockford.

Rockford is hurting our communities level of RP and honestly limiting our capacity for growth

[Soviethooves]

Was that directed to me?

[Bambo]

[Soviethooves]

It's a little pathetic how hard you're trying to push your favor of Rockford tbh, community poll currently stands that more people want V5P.

Amazing how that works out. Push hard for Rockford, you get Rockford. Push hard for v5p, you get v5p.

Even the previous map vote showed a favor of V5P over Rockford on the forums, but I bet you pushed really hard to get it into the F1 menu so randoms can vote on it and you could really push for it on players in-game. Bet if I was active at that time, it'd have a different outcome because I'm sure after explaining all the cons to Rockford and the pros to V5P the vote would've had a different outcome

Which map vote? The one that was 50/50, the one that guy Rockford by 5-6 votes before beign concluded, or the voting poll IG that had Rockford majority?

Rockford zero RP value,

Your opinion

crap buildings,

They're actually well done, but sadly some have pre-placed items inside.

crap roads,

The roads were one of the bigger things that players liked about Rockford. The highway allowed it to not hit any dead ends.

crap police station,

(Your Opinion) That's a nice PD. Only downside is small jails. And the HUGE EMS/FD building. Way too big.

no offices,

Make one. There was an office on v4b1, but most people opted to make their offices elsewhere.

no room for clan builds (reason why every admin clan builds custom areas),

Use any part of the map that you can find. Just add a foundation to it.

no city feeling,

Your opinion. I honestly get the feeling 50/50 now.

crap optimization (literally giant buildings and blocks textured as trees),

GM issue, not map issue. This was already found out and I believe v5p has the same situation. Good map, but the lag is coming from the GM.

fire station that is bigger than all passive rp stores combined,

Agreed, but the store thing is honestly because there is no incentive to do it.

empty spaces everywhere that don't look good,

Your opinion. Most of the empty spaces people have used and made really nice dupes.

invisible walls,

Where the 3-4 tunnels are that are blocked off, yes.

fake buildings everywhere that you can't access,

Same thing in v5p, v4b1, pretty much any RP map.

town hall sucks with a basic courtroom on the floor level that nobody is going to use because it doesn't look like a court room,

So what else should we put there? A useless room like a CIA office that no one will use?

bank that has a broken vault that glitches through the map,

Gotta agree, it breaks a good bit.

slums across from town hall?,

Welcome to the city. Poor people live in most areas. v2d have them right outside the Nexus too.

gas station stores that are filled and cannot be used for any RP,

Gas Stations that are filled with gas station stuff so people can RP a gas station as a gas station and not a gun store.

mesa apartments that are crap and don't actually offer room for additional RP ideas such as running an apartment building or hotel and having a reception area to check people in,

How so? I've seen a few players do it.

cinema that takes up a good chunk of the upper city and isn't used/needed,

I believe there is a suggestion on it.

shops facing a cliff near inner shell that have low visibility and foot traffic and nobody uses,

Agreed, however they are still used and traveled.

RTA/Realtor buildings are ugly asf and can't be used for RP,

Your opinion and they have been used for multiple RP's. Ain't hard to make it work if you got imagination.

industrial area that doesn't even look good and is placed next to downtown and makes it a 10 second drive from PD and has high foot traffic so this makes these areas useless for actual criminal builds not to mention the industrial spaces are huge boxes with poor lighting making them impossible to properly decorate or use for RP (exception being when you're an admin with unlimited props), industrial area middle building isn't used because it's crap and uses flat PHX materials for the exterior and interior and has no room for any meaningful RP usage,

They're used all the time for successful RP's, what are you talking about?

three copy and pasted warehouses outside of town lack any good qualities for RP builds, just randomly placed at the end of a road,

That are used often and well by criminals and gov alike.

pier is sad waterfront builds are hideous,

That's a little rude to the players that make them and that's not a map problem?

lake homes are probably the only semi-decent buildings on the map along with the tavern and some suburban homes, and they are only used for contraband for that reason.

Welcome to LL. That's what most buildings are used for.

GM is a waste of space, filled with crap and look terrible.

Your argument against evocity was that you liked it

Also everything Bambo, myself, and all the supporters of Rockford have mentioned.

but that it's sticking in the past and that it's a lagfest and that it's too spaced out,

Lag isn't the map's fault. It's our GM and the map is actually quite well spaced out. V5p is in the same boat.

however as stated in the thread those things aren't true. We've never run V5P, it's the same if not better in optimization as Rockford and it functions just as well with 50 players on. There's nobody being spread out hiding, people would actually use the downtown to RP and not be cramped at 190 Main St which is the standalone box shop on Rockford.

Yea, I remember the same thing not happening when we had v4b1. Many the shops were used once and everyone else would be outside the city basing.

Rockford is hurting our communities level of RP and honestly limiting our capacity for growth

How so? We've seen an increase in peak days since the switch according to some players.

[roxas]

I don't even get this discussion.. There has been a vote. Rockford was the community's choice.
Just because like 10 people in game or in the forums are now changing their mind and cry that they desperately want to have V5P, the map won't get changed I think. You are not representative for the whole community of actually hundrets of people.

I admit that I am not that big of a fan of Rockford. But:

Rockford won the vote - deal with it. Every map has it's up and down sides.

[Nev]

I don't even get this discussion.. There has been a vote. Rockford was the community's choice.
Just because like 10 people in game or in the forums are now changing their mind and cry that they desperately want to have V5P, the map won't get changed I think. You are not representative for the whole community of actually hundrets of people.

I admit that I am not that big of a fan of Rockford. But:

Rockford won the vote - deal with it. Every map has it's up and down sides.

https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-17617.html

(33) EvoCity V5P / (12) Rockford

First map-vote was fairly close and the community has been split on both of these map choices - therefore it makes sense to rotate V5P in a cycle and accomodate both groups. No reason to create a split over something that has a way to satisfy both parties.

[Soviethooves]

After 3 votes were held prior to Rockford becoming a thing

[BlackDog]

I still like the rotation idea

1w Rockford, 1W V5d, etc.

Best of both worlds and keeps things fresh

[Murdoch Murdoch]

Rockford is trying way too hard to be something it can't. No matter how much better the textures are or how much artificial quality they pump into it it's just not evocity. Rockford is like that weird flavour of ice cream which is kinda cool but you won't try it more than a few times, just stick with the vanilla, chocolate and strawberry of evocity. V5p isn't exactly compact, but neither is rockford, but what v5p does have is more than one usable, simple shop on the fucking main street and even more just around the corner from nexus if I remember correctly.

Map rotation is a bad idea as well you may as well just have 2 separate servers at that point. Don't force/funnel players into one thing if you're gonna give them a taste of the other on the horizon, they'll just sit back and wait. Whatever decision you make it has to be permanent.