Limelight Forums
How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? - Printable Version

+- Limelight Forums (https://limelightgaming.net/forums)
+-- Forum: Entertainment (https://limelightgaming.net/forums/forum-197.html)
+--- Forum: Discussions (https://limelightgaming.net/forums/forum-223.html)
+--- Thread: How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? (/thread-25278.html)

Pages: 1 2

How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? - Nebula - Jun 5, 2019

I see a thread with like 10 +supports and 3 -supports: It gets declined
then there are threads with 2+supports and 2- supports: Staff review

Uh? What. How does this work I am courius what factors are decding wether a suggestion is declined or under staff review even though (at some suggestions) the community clearly voted for it.

RE: How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? - Zaidplays - Jun 5, 2019

Yeah i get you dude, its confusing AF.

RE: How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? - pufitee - Jun 5, 2019

docs spaget code

RE: How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? - Dick - Jun 5, 2019

Most suggestion threads go through Staff Review unless it receives around a very large percentage of -support out of a total of votes which I also don't know the number of. Some suggestions are automatically denied due them being large changes being reverted for instance the HUD revert threads we had many months ago. Another example of suggestions getting denied is failing to follow guidelines or even a suggestion that is on the DO NOT suggest thread.

@Doctor Internet‍ always provides the reasons as to why something is denied. This being from a direct reasons or opinions giving examples from the staff team if it went through the staff review previously.

RE: How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? - Jeff Ford - Jun 5, 2019

Democracy isn't a thing here.

RE: How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? - Vinic - Jun 6, 2019

ThAnK yOu fOr YoUr SuGgEsTiOn. hOwEvEr, ThE dEveLoPmEnT teAm hAvE dEteRmInEd ThAt ThE iMpLeMeNtAtiOn oF tHiS sUgGeStiOn WoUlD bE uNfEaSiBlE oR nOnViaBle At teH cUrReNt TiMe, AnD tHuS iT hAs BeEn DeNieD.

RE: How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? - Doctor Internet - Jun 6, 2019

Which threads @Nebula?

RE: How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? - Lord Octagon - Jun 6, 2019

(Jun 6, 2019, 01:26 AM)Theo Wrote: ThAnK yOu fOr YoUr SuGgEsTiOn. hOwEvEr, ThE dEveLoPmEnT teAm hAvE dEteRmInEd ThAt ThE iMpLeMeNtAtiOn oF tHiS sUgGeStiOn WoUlD bE uNfEaSiBlE oR nOnViaBle At teH cUrReNt TiMe, AnD tHuS iT hAs BeEn DeNieD.

The message is verbose as fuck.

RE: How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? - George - Jun 8, 2019

(Jun 5, 2019, 08:32 PM)Jeff Ford Wrote: Democracy isn't a thing here.



Well yeah, it's a company. 

Sure, the staff can ask for community input but at the of the day the staff have the final say in what does and does not happen.

RE: How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? - Nudel - Jun 8, 2019

(Jun 8, 2019, 02:13 PM)George Wrote:
(Jun 5, 2019, 08:32 PM)Jeff Ford Wrote: Democracy isn't a thing here.



Well yeah, it's a company. 

Sure, the staff can ask for community input but at the of the day the staff have the final say in what does and does not happen.

But in the end, the community is funding it?

RE: How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? - Dick - Jun 8, 2019

(Jun 8, 2019, 04:15 PM)Nudelsalat im Panzer Wrote:
(Jun 8, 2019, 02:13 PM)George Wrote:
(Jun 5, 2019, 08:32 PM)Jeff Ford Wrote: Democracy isn't a thing here.



Well yeah, it's a company. 

Sure, the staff can ask for community input but at the of the day the staff have the final say in what does and does not happen.

But in the end, the community is funding it?

But in the end, its a company and checking the previous month's store purchases, I doubt it is leading to the community funding all services/developer paychecks with £369.07 on the table.

RE: How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? - Nebula - Jun 9, 2019

(Jun 6, 2019, 09:59 AM)Doctor Internet Wrote: Which threads @Nebula?


For the 3+ 3- and being approved I gotta say I didnt count in the poll.
Well either way examples for Community support but nope:

https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-24935-page-2.html
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-24632-page-2.html
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-24342.html
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-23900.html


I have to admit that recently they have been fairly community ish. But I remember very well times were it very much felt it was random.

RE: How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? - Doctor Internet - Jun 9, 2019

One of the suggestions has already been handled and so it was closed.

The other three all got to staff review, were reviewed by staff and then denied.

Pretty clear?

RE: How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? - Nudel - Jun 9, 2019

(Jun 9, 2019, 11:56 AM)Nebula Wrote:
(Jun 6, 2019, 09:59 AM)Doctor Internet Wrote: Which threads @Nebula?


For the 3+ 3- and being approved I gotta say I didnt count in the poll.
Well either way examples for Community support but nope:

https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-24935-page-2.html
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-24632-page-2.html
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-24342.html
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-23900.html


I have to admit that recently they have been fairly community ish. But I remember very well times were it very much felt it was random.

https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-9603.html    |  27 +supports -> denied
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-18189.html  |  15 +supports -> denied
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-13780.html  |    9 +supports -> denied
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-23406.html  |  14 +supports -> denied
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-10375.html  |  42 +supports -> denied
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-5719.html    |  26 +supports -> denied
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-9295.html    |  23 +supports -> denied
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-6211.html    |  20 +supports -> denied

Quote:Thank you for your suggestion. However, this suggestion has failed to pass a staff vote, and has therefore been denied at the current time. However, please feel free to re-suggest this in the future.

Quote:Thank you for your suggestion. However, the development team have determined that the implementation of this suggestion would be unfeasible or nonviable at the current time, and thus it has been denied.

yeet

[Image: M1Z8oxI.gif]

RE: How does the suggestion decline/Staff review work? - Dick - Jun 9, 2019

(Jun 9, 2019, 02:22 PM)Nudelsalat im Panzer Wrote: https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-9603.html    |  27 +supports -> denied
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-18189.html  |  15 +supports -> denied
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-13780.html  |    9 +supports -> denied
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-23406.html  |  14 +supports -> denied
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-10375.html  |  42 +supports -> denied
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-5719.html    |  26 +supports -> denied
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-9295.html    |  23 +supports -> denied
https://limelightgaming.net/forums/thread-6211.html    |  20 +supports -> denied

So, you think using threads from 2017 and prior is a good use of evidence to for references for today's standards.